No international rule separates a hill from a mountain, but the usual dividing line is height: in the UK and Ireland a summit of at least 610 m (2,000 ft) is a mountain and anything lower is a hill, while the United States once used 1,000 ft (305 m) and has since dropped any official definition. In practice a mountain is also steeper, rises more abruptly above its surroundings and usually has a more defined peak, while a hill is lower and rounder. Local custom often overrides the numbers, which is why Scots routinely call even their highest peaks “hills”, South Dakota’s 2,208-metre Black Elk Peak sits in the Black Hills, and a rise just 42 metres above the plain in Victoria, Australia, is Mount Wycheproof.
The 1,000-Foot Rule, the 2,000-Foot Rule and the 600-Metre Line
Most attempts to define the difference pick a height, and they disagree about which one. Geographers historically treated a mountain as a hill more than 1,000 feet (304.8 m) above sea level. The United States Board on Geographic Names used that figure for a time, then abandoned it in the 1970s; the US Geological Survey now says the words have no technical definitions in the country. British hillwalkers settled on 2,000 feet (610 m), which is also the limit suggested by the Oxford English Dictionary. John Whittow’s Dictionary of Physical Geography rounds it to metres: “some authorities” treat eminences above 600 m (1,969 ft) as mountains and those below as hills. The UK’s Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000 used the same 600-metre line to define mountain land for its public access rules.
Other traditions measure from the base rather than from the sea. The Great Soviet Encyclopedia defined a hill as an upland with a relative height of up to 200 m (660 ft). That approach captures something a sea-level rule misses: a summit on a high plateau may stand thousands of metres above the ocean but barely rise above the ground around it.
The most detailed attempt is the mountain definition used by the UN Environment Programme. It sorts land into seven classes, from anything above 4,500 m down to land between 300 and 1,000 m that has at least 300 m of relief within 7 km. Only the lower classes need a slope or relief test; above 2,500 m, height alone is enough. By that standard about 24% of Earth’s land is mountainous.
Cavanal Hill, Oklahoma: The “World’s Highest Hill” at 1,999 Feet
Height thresholds invite boundary disputes, and Cavanal Hill near Poteau, Oklahoma, has made a tourist attraction of one. A sign at its base calls it the “World’s Highest Hill”, with an elevation of 1,999 feet, one foot short of the 2,000-foot mark. The real summit is 2,385 feet (727 m) above sea level, and the climb from the Poteau River 5 km to the north is 1,960 feet (600 m). The sign uses the rise above the base, not the height above the sea, and even then it depends on choosing 2,000 rather than 1,000 feet as the cutoff. Its official name, awkwardly for the slogan, is Cavanal Mountain.
The French explorers who named it in the 18th century did not worry about the distinction; they used the hill as a landmark, and fur trappers at its base founded Poteau, from the French for “post”. The botanist Thomas Nuttall studied its plant life in 1819, and in the late 1800s Walter Beard opened a health resort, a modest wood-frame building, on the summit.
Mynydd Graig Goch and Garth Hill: Six Inches and Sixteen Feet
In Britain the 2,000-foot line has real consequences, because hillwalkers keep lists. Mynydd Graig Goch, the western peak of the Nantlle Ridge in Snowdonia, was left off lists of Welsh 2,000-foot mountains for years because Ordnance Survey maps gave it a spot height of 609 m (1,998 ft). In 2008 a group of hillwalkers carried out a precise GPS survey and measured it at 609.75 m, or 2,000 ft 6 in. Six inches turned a hill into a mountain, and it is now the most westerly 2,000-foot peak in Wales. Its name, fittingly, means “mountain of the red rock”.
The same tension drives the 1995 film The Englishman Who Went Up a Hill But Came Down a Mountain. Set in 1917, it follows two English map-makers who measure a Welsh village’s “mountain” at 984 feet, 16 feet short of the 1,000-foot threshold they are using, prompting the villagers to pile earth on the summit. The story came from the director Christopher Monger’s grandfather and was inspired by Garth Hill above Taff’s Well, north of Cardiff, though the film was shot in Powys.
Munros and Marilyns: Height Versus Prominence
A pure height rule ignores how much a summit actually stands out. The British lists show both approaches. A Munro is a Scottish mountain above 3,000 ft (914.4 m) that appears on the Scottish Mountaineering Club’s list, with no explicit prominence test. Sir Hugh Munro published the first list in 1891, and as of December 2020 there were 282 Munros, with Ben Nevis, at 1,345 m the highest mountain in the British Isles, the best known. Before Munro’s Tables, nobody agreed how many Scottish summits passed 3,000 feet: published estimates ranged from 31 to 236. Climbing them all, known as Munro bagging, became a pastime of its own; Hamish Brown completed the first continuous round in 1974, and 7,654 people had reported a full round by the end of 2023. Yet Scots often call these peaks hills, as in the Cuillin Hills of Skye.
A Marilyn, by contrast, ignores absolute height. It is any summit in Britain or Ireland with a topographic prominence of at least 150 m (492 ft), meaning you must drop at least 150 m before you can climb to anything higher. Alan Dawson defined the list in his 1992 book The Relative Hills of Britain, punning on Monroe; there were 2,010 Marilyns as of July 2023. Ben Nevis qualifies, but Cairn Gorm, a Munro at 1,245 m (4,085 ft) and the sixth-highest mountain in the British Isles, does not, because it is a shoulder of higher ground rather than a free-standing summit. Prominence is the measure closest to the everyday sense of a mountain as something that towers over its surroundings, and some definitions of a mountain require 300 m of it.
Black Hills, Sivalik Hills and Mount Wycheproof: Names That Break the Rules
Place names often predate any definition and ignore them. The Black Hills of South Dakota are geologically part of the Rocky Mountain system, and their highest point, Black Elk Peak, stands at 2,208 m (7,244 ft), more than three times the British mountain threshold. In South Asia the Sivalik Hills run about 2,400 km along the outer edge of the Himalayas from the Indus to near the Brahmaputra, with an average elevation of 1,500 to 2,000 m. They are called hills because they are dwarfed by the Himalayan ranges behind them, a reminder that the label is relative to the landscape. They are also geologically young: their sandstones and conglomerates are debris eroded from the Himalayas and are thought to be between 16 and 5.2 million years old.
The reverse happens too. Mount Wycheproof in Victoria, Australia, rises only 42 m (138 ft) above the surrounding plain and 147 m above sea level, yet it is still called a mountain, and the town of Wycheproof is built on its south-western slopes. In very flat country, even a modest rise stands out enough to earn the grander word. Rome’s seven hills show the same flexibility in Latin: the Palatine appears as both Collis and Mons Palatinus, “hill” and “mountain”, while the Capitoline was Mons Capitolinus.
Buttes, Mesas and Knolls: How Hills Form Differently from Mountains
Origin offers another, looser way to tell them apart. Large mountain ranges are mostly built by plate tectonics, through crust colliding, folding and faulting, or by volcanoes. Hills form in more varied ways. Some are worn-down remnants of old mountains, some are pushed up by faulting, and many are made of debris left by glaciers, such as moraines and the long, whale-shaped hills called drumlins. Their rounded tops come from soil creeping slowly downslope, which softens the summit over time.
Several look-alike landforms sit between the two words. A mesa, from the Spanish for “table”, is an isolated flat-topped hill with steep sides, protected by a cap of hard rock such as sandstone. A butte, from a French word for “knoll”, is a smaller eroded mesa; the rule of thumb is that a mesa’s top is wider than its height and a butte’s is narrower. The Mitten Buttes of Monument Valley are the standard examples. A knoll or hillock is simply a small hill, and a tor is a rocky outcrop on a hilltop, a name used especially in south-west England and the Peak District. Central Europe has the Kuppe, a rounded hill or low mountain, and the Auvergne in France has the puy, a conical volcanic hill; both words sit in the grey zone between the two categories.
If you want to see how mountain heights are measured, and why surveys like the one on Mynydd Graig Goch matter, read our guide on how mountains are measured; the tectonic side of the story is covered in how mountains are formed.
