Types of Economies: Traditional, Command, Market and Mixed Compared
Source: Wikimedia Commons
Geography Guides

Types of Economies: Traditional, Command, Market and Mixed Compared

Who decides what gets made: custom, planners, prices or a mix? A side-by-side comparison of the four types of economies, with examples and spending figures.

Geography Worlds
March 26, 2026
Updated October 6, 2026
8 min read

Economists usually sort economies into four types by who decides what gets produced, how and for whom. In a traditional economy custom and kinship decide, as among the Hadza foragers of Tanzania; in a command economy the state plans production, as Gosplan did in the Soviet Union from 1921 to 1991 and as North Korea still largely does; in a market economy prices set by supply and demand decide, the system Adam Smith described in The Wealth of Nations in 1776; and a mixed economy combines private markets with public services and regulation. No country runs a pure version of any of them. Today the dominant form worldwide is the market-oriented mixed economy, but the mix varies widely: in 2018 general government spending was about 56 % of GDP in France and 25 % in Ireland.

Set side by side, the four types differ mainly in two things: who makes the decisions, and who owns the land and capital.

TypeWho decidesWho owns land and capitalExample
TraditionalCustom, family and community obligationsHouseholds, clans, customary groupsHadza of Tanzania; subsistence farming in Papua New Guinea
Command (planned)Central planners and the ruling partyMostly the state and collectivesSoviet Union 1928–1991; North Korea; Cuba
MarketBuyers and sellers, through pricesMostly privateHong Kong, ranked freest economy 1995–2019 by the Index of Economic Freedom
MixedMarkets, with government regulation, taxes and public servicesPrivate, with public utilities and servicesFrance, Germany, the United States, the Nordic countries

Market Economy vs Command Economy: Hong Kong and the Soviet Union

The sharpest contrast is between the two systems that dominated the twentieth-century argument. A market economy allocates investment, labour and land through price signals. When a good becomes scarce its price rises, which tells producers to make more of it and consumers to use less, without anyone directing either. Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations, published on 9 March 1776, framed this with the metaphor of an “invisible hand”: individuals pursuing their own interest, he argued, often promote the interest of society. Market economies still sit along a spectrum, from lightly regulated systems where the state mostly protects property and provides public goods, to interventionist ones where it steers investment through industrial policy.

At the lightly regulated end, Hong Kong became the textbook case. The Heritage Foundation’s Index of Economic Freedom ranked it the world’s freest economy in every edition from the first in 1995 until 2019, a run of 25 years. In 2021 the index stopped scoring Hong Kong and Macau separately, saying their policies were ultimately controlled from Beijing.

A command economy replaces prices with a plan. In the Soviet Union the State Planning Committee, Gosplan, was set up in 1921 and drew up a series of five-year plans that told factories and farms what to produce and in what quantity. The first plan, announced on 1 October 1928 and run to 31 December 1932, put about 86 % of industrial investment into heavy industry and was officially declared fulfilled in four years and three months. Gosplan launched thirteen five-year plans in all; the last, for 1991–1995, was abandoned when the Soviet Union was dissolved in 1991. Planners could mobilise resources quickly for steel, tractors or armaments, but without prices they had no easy way to know what consumers actually wanted.

The command model survives most fully in North Korea, which follows the Juche ideology of self-reliance. Its GDP was estimated at about $28.5 billion in 2016. After the economic collapse of the 1990s, informal markets known as jangmadang spread because the state could no longer distribute enough food, and in 2021 South Korea’s Ministry of Unification estimated that the private sector had outgrown the public one. That same year the 8th Congress of the Workers’ Party of Korea began pulling the economy back toward central control. Cuba also runs a command economy dominated by state enterprises; its GDP fell 33 % between 1990 and 1993 when Soviet subsidies, worth between 10 % and 40 % of GDP in different years, disappeared.

Traditional Economies: The Hadza, the Kula Ring and Papua New Guinea

A traditional economy is the loosest of the four labels. It usually describes a society with only weak links to wider trade, where most people grow, herd or gather their own food, barter is more common than money, and family and clan decide who gets what. Unlike a command economy there is no central planner, and unlike a market economy prices play a minor role.

The Hadza of northern Tanzania, who live around the Lake Eyasi basin, are one of the last nomadic hunter-gatherer societies. They traditionally live in camps of about 20 to 30 people, with egalitarian, non-hierarchical social structures, and eat mostly honey, tubers, fruit and, in the dry season especially, meat. In 2015 there were between 1,200 and 1,300 Hadza, of whom only around a third still lived exclusively by foraging.

A Hadza hunter holding a bow and arrows standing in front of his house in Tanzania
A Hadza hunter with his bow in front of his house, Tanzania. Photo: Erasmus Kamugisha, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Traditional exchange is not always simple barter. In the Kula ring of Milne Bay Province, Papua New Guinea, islanders made dangerous sea voyages around the Trobriand Islands and their neighbours to pass on shell necklaces and bracelets as gifts, an exchange tied to political authority rather than profit. Bronisław Malinowski’s Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922) made the Kula the classic case study of a gift economy, and Marcel Mauss built on it in The Gift (1925).

Few whole countries are traditional economies, but many contain a large traditional sector. In Papua New Guinea about 75 % of people rely mainly on the subsistence economy and agriculture supports some 85 % of the population, even though mineral deposits, including oil, copper and gold, earn about 72 % of export earnings. The country is therefore a mix of a customary economy and a market one, with smallholders blurring the line by growing coffee, cocoa and copra for sale.

Mixed Economies, From France’s 56 % to Ireland’s 25 %

A mixed economy keeps private ownership and profit-seeking enterprise as its engine but gives the state a large role in regulation, welfare and public services such as schools, hospitals and infrastructure. The idea is associated with John Maynard Keynes, who argued that governments should use fiscal and monetary policy to counteract capitalism’s cycles of boom and bust. In Britain the Conservative politician Harold Macmillan championed a similar middle course in The Middle Way (1938), and the term “mixed economy” itself came out of British postwar debate. In Western Europe’s postwar mixed economies, public ownership typically covered around 15 to 20 % of the economy, mostly utilities and essential services.

The clearest way to compare mixed economies is the share of national output that passes through government. Across the European Union, public spending was 46.7 % of GDP in 2018, and almost 20 % of EU GDP went on social protection alone. Within the EU the range was wide.

France56 %
Finland53 %
EU average46.7 %
Ireland25 %
General government spending as a share of GDP in 2018: the highest and lowest EU members against the EU average. Source: Wikipedia, Government spending (2018 EU figures)

The mix has also shifted over time. At the end of the nineteenth century, public spending in industrial countries averaged around 10 % of GDP, and only about 7 % in the United States. The world wars, the New Deal and the postwar welfare states pushed it up in steps, and between 1960 and 1980 the average jumped from about 28 % to 43 %, with Belgium, Sweden and the Netherlands above 50 %.

Late 1800s10 %
Before 191412 %
193722.5 %
196028 %
198043 %
199645 %
Average public expenditure as a share of GDP in industrialised countries, showing how market economies became mixed ones (1937 is the midpoint of a 22–23 % estimate). Source: Wikipedia, Government spending

Look-Alikes: Germany’s Social Market, the Nordic Model and China’s Socialist Market

Several named models sit inside the mixed category and are easy to confuse. Germany’s social market economy (soziale Marktwirtschaft) was introduced in West Germany by Konrad Adenauer’s Christian Democratic Union in 1949, drawing on the ordoliberal ideas of the interwar Freiburg school. It deliberately does not plan production. Instead it relies on competitive markets, backed by strong competition law and a welfare state that protects people who cannot work because of age, disability or unemployment. Austria, Belgium, the Netherlands and Switzerland are among the countries usually grouped with it. The Nordic model of Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden is usually compared with it as another regional form of welfare capitalism.

China’s socialist market economy looks similar from a distance but starts from the other end: it is a former command economy that has let markets in. The reform and opening-up programme began on 18 December 1978 under Deng Xiaoping. It broke up the people’s communes, relaxed price controls, admitted foreign investment and created special economic zones such as Shenzhen. The Shanghai Stock Exchange was re-established in November 1990 and China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001, while private enterprises were allowed to grow and many state-owned enterprises were scaled down or privatised, all under the continued rule of the Communist Party.

High-rise towers of Futian District in Shenzhen rising above green hills under a cloudy sky
The skyline of Futian District, Shenzhen, the most prominent of the special economic zones created after 1978. Photo: Huangdan2060, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The growth that followed shows up plainly in the numbers. China’s economy grew from about $150 billion in 1978 to about $18.74 trillion in 2024, extreme poverty fell by some 800 million people between 1978 and 2018, and since 2016 China has been the world’s largest economy measured by purchasing power parity.

Placing the United States, Germany, China and the Hadza on the Spectrum

Because every real economy is a blend, the useful question is not “which type is it?” but “where does it sit between the poles?” Three tests do most of the work. First, ask who sets most prices: a planning agency, as in the Soviet Union or North Korea, or buyers and sellers, as in Hong Kong. Second, ask who owns the factories, land and banks: mostly the state, mostly private firms, or households and clans, as in Papua New Guinea’s subsistence sector. Third, ask how much of GDP the government spends, from roughly a quarter in Ireland to over half in France. By those tests the United States, Germany and France are all mixed market economies that differ in degree, China is a mixed economy built out of a command one, and the Hadza remain one of the few genuinely traditional economies left.

For the countries still closest to the planned end of the spectrum, see our explainer on command economy countries and the current list of communist countries; for how the two largest mixed models work in detail, compare the economy of Germany with the economy of China.

Recently updated guides