What Is a Butte? How Caprock and Cliff Retreat Leave Lone Hills Standing
Source: Wikimedia Commons
Geographic Features

What Is a Butte? How Caprock and Cliff Retreat Leave Lone Hills Standing

A butte is an isolated, steep-walled hill whose flat top is narrower than its height. Here is how caprock, basal sapping and retreating cliffs make them, with Monument Valley, Devils Tower and Chimney Rock as examples.

Geography Worlds
March 26, 2026
Updated October 6, 2026
8 min read

A butte is an isolated hill with steep, often vertical sides and a small, relatively flat top, and by the geographers’ rule of thumb it is taller than its summit is wide. Buttes form when a hard caprock sits on softer rock: erosion strips away the soft layers around it, the cliffs retreat, and a shrinking remnant of a former plateau or mesa is left standing alone. The textbook examples are the West and East Mitten Buttes in Monument Valley on the Arizona–Utah line, whose summits reach 1,882 m and 1,898 m above sea level, and Devils Tower in Wyoming, an igneous butte standing 264 m from base to summit. The word itself is French for a knoll, and it is used mostly in the western United States, where the larger version of the same landform is called by the Spanish word mesa.

Map marking the location of Monument Valley
Monument Valley, at 37.0°N, 110.1°W, on a Geography Worlds map drawn from Natural Earth boundary data (dashed lines mark disputed boundaries).

Caprock Over Shale: The Differential Erosion Behind Every Butte

Every butte begins as part of something larger. In the Colorado Plateau and the Great Plains, flat-lying beds of sedimentary rock were laid down one on top of another and later lifted by tectonic movement. Those beds are not equally tough. Sandstone, conglomerate, limestone, basalt lava flows and igneous sills resist weathering well; shale and siltstone crumble easily. Geologists call the result differential erosion: water, frost and wind cut down through the weak layers much faster than through the strong ones, so whatever lies under a resistant cap is protected while the land around it is lowered.

The decisive process happens at the foot of the cliff, not the top. Rain running off the summit and groundwater seeping through permeable layers soak the soft shale at the base, which slumps and washes away. This is basal sapping. Once the shale has been undercut, the caprock above it has nothing to rest on, and blocks break off along vertical joints and crash down. The fallen debris piles up as a talus or scree slope around the base, is weathered in turn, and is carried off by streams or wind, which exposes fresh shale to be undercut again. Repeated over millions of years, this marches a cliff line backwards.

Where streams cut back into a plateau edge unevenly, they slice off detached blocks. A block that is still broad is a mesa; as its edges keep collapsing, the summit shrinks until only a narrow cap remains, and it becomes a butte. Push the process further and the butte thins into a spire or pinnacle, and finally the last of the caprock falls and the softer rock beneath erodes to a low mound. On a far smaller scale, the same caprock-and-collapse mechanism produces hoodoos, the slim rock columns of places such as Bryce Canyon.

Davis, Penck and Lester King: Arguing Over How Cliffs Retreat

The idea that a butte is a stage in the life of a landscape owes much to the explorers of the American West after the Civil War. John Wesley Powell, Clarence Dutton and Grove Karl Gilbert described the plateaus and canyons of Utah and Arizona in the 1870s, and their reports fed directly into the most influential landscape theory of the next half-century. William Morris Davis first set out his cycle of erosion in detail in 1889. He described landscapes passing through youth, maturity and old age, ending as a low, rolling plain he called a peneplain, studded with residual hills.

Davis’s model had a problem with buttes. In it, slopes evolve by decline: steep valley sides are gradually worn into gentler and gentler slopes. But a butte keeps near-vertical walls right to the end of its life. The German geomorphologist Walther Penck challenged Davis with a different model, published posthumously by his father Albrecht in 1924, in which relief depends on the balance between uplift and denudation. The South African geologist Lester King went further in his 1942 book South African Scenery, arguing for parallel scarp retreat: cliffs keep their steepness while they back away, leaving broad gently sloping pediments in front of them. In King’s pediplain, the leftover hills ought to keep the same steep profile as the original escarpment, which is precisely the shape of a butte.

A study published in 2006 found that cliffs on the Colorado Plateau are retreating at between 0.5 and 6.7 km per million years, depending on how thick and resistant the caprock is.

Colorado Plateau (fastest)6.7 km/Myr
Great Escarpment, Australia2.0 km/Myr
Morocco, thin conglomerate cap1.3 km/Myr
Morocco, thick limestone cap0.5 km/Myr
Colorado Plateau (slowest)0.5 km/Myr
Measured rates of scarp retreat in kilometres per million years: the thicker and tougher the caprock, the slower the cliff backs away and the longer a butte survives. Source: Wikipedia, “Scarp retreat”, citing published field studies

Mesa, Butte or Pinnacle? The Height-to-Width Test

There is no agreed size limit separating these landforms, so geographers use proportions instead. A mesa has a summit wider than it is high; a butte has a summit narrower than it is high. The geologist Kirk Bryan wrote in 1922 that mesas stand above the surrounding country “as a table stands above the floor”, and the comparison holds for buttes too: they are the table worn down to a single leg. Size alone tells you little. Flat-topped hills in the Cockburn Range of Western Australia are called mesas at up to 350 km², while in Germany’s Elbe Sandstone Mountains table hills as small as 0.1 km² carry the same name. The difference between a mesa and a butte is shape, not area.

Local vocabulary varies as well: Venezuela has tepuis, Australia has tablehills or jump-ups, and German writers used Tafelberg.

West and East Mitten Buttes: Sandstone Remnants in Monument Valley

The sedimentary butte in its purest form stands in Monument Valley, on the Navajo Nation along the Arizona–Utah state line. The valley floor lies 1,500 to 1,800 m above sea level, and the largest buttes rise about 300 m above it. Each one is a layered column of three principal units: Organ Rock Shale at the base, de Chelly Sandstone forming the sheer walls, and the Moenkopi Formation on top, capped by the hard Shinarump Conglomerate. That conglomerate cap is what has kept the Mittens standing while the land around them has been stripped away.

West Mitten Butte reaches 1,882 m and East Mitten Butte 1,898 m. Seen from the south, each has a slender spire beside its main block, the inward-facing “thumb” that gives them their name; that spire is a further stage of the same retreat, a sliver of wall being split from the parent butte. Merrick Butte stands about 1.1 km to the south, and Sentinel Mesa, a much broader table, lies to the north-west, so a visitor can see mesa, butte and spire within a single view. For a few days around late March and mid-September, the setting sun casts the West Mitten’s shadow onto the East Mitten. John Ford filmed Stagecoach (1939) and The Searchers (1956) here, fixing these buttes as the image of the American West.

Devils Tower and Bear Butte: Laccoliths Exposed by Erosion

Not every butte is sedimentary. In 1877 Grove Karl Gilbert published The Geology of the Henry Mountains, describing in Utah a kind of intrusion he found there: a body of magma that spread sideways between rock layers and domed them upwards before it cooled. These are laccoliths, and because cooled igneous rock is far tougher than the sandstone and shale around it, erosion later carves them out as isolated, steep-sided hills.

Devils Tower in north-eastern Wyoming is the best-known result. About 40.5 million years ago, phonolite porphyry magma intruded the Triassic and Jurassic sediments of the area and cooled into hexagonal columns up to 6.1 m wide and 180 m tall. In 1907 the geologists Nelson Horatio Darton and C. C. O’Harra proposed that the tower is the eroded remnant of a laccolith, although with the surrounding rock gone, its original shape can no longer be reconstructed for certain. It rises 386 m above the Belle Fourche River and 264 m from its base to its summit at 1,558 m. Columns still break away, and the scree around the foot shows that the tower was once wider. President Theodore Roosevelt made it the first United States national monument on 24 September 1906. The Lakota call it Matȟó Thípila, Bear Lodge, and a 2014 proposal to adopt that name officially was not accepted.

Devils Tower in Wyoming seen from the south-east, its grey vertical rock columns rising above a slope of pine trees
Devils Tower, Wyoming, from the south-east: the vertical cooling columns of phonolite porphyry form the walls of this igneous butte. Photo: DXR, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Across the state line, Bear Butte near Sturgis, South Dakota, comes from the same Eocene episode of intrusions that produced Devils Tower and the nearby Missouri Buttes. Strictly it is a laccolith rather than a butte, because it was not carved from flat-lying sediment, and its top is a peak rather than a table. It rises 382 m above the plain to 1,349 m. To the Lakota it is Matȟó Pahá, Bear Mountain; it became a South Dakota state park in 1961, and pilgrims still leave prayer cloths on its trees.

Sutter Buttes and Black Butte: Volcanoes That Kept the Name

Further west, the word drifts even further from its strict meaning. The Sutter Buttes rise out of the flat Sacramento Valley near Yuba City, California: a ring of eroded volcanic lava domes about 16 km across, often called the world’s smallest mountain range. Their highest point, South Butte, is 647 m. In central Oregon, Black Butte is an extinct stratovolcano of basaltic andesite on the Cascade arc, a nearly symmetrical cone rising to 1,962 m whose northern base feeds the springs of the Metolius River. Neither has a flat top, and Crested Butte in Colorado is a 3,709 m mountain. These are buttes by name and local habit only.

Chimney Rock: The Last Stage Before a Butte Disappears

The end of the sequence can be seen in the North Platte valley of western Nebraska. Chimney Rock is built mostly of Brule clay interlayered with volcanic ash, topped by harder Arikaree sandstone. Its peak stands 1,289 m above sea level and about 87 m above its surroundings. The sandstone layers near the top have protected the pillar since it broke away from the cliff line to the south as that cliff retreated, so it is a detached outlier in the most literal sense: the conical base is soft clay slumping away, and the spire is the last stub of resistant rock.

Chimney Rock in western Nebraska, a narrow rock spire on top of a broad eroded cone, with cattle grazing on the plain below
Chimney Rock, Nebraska: a sandstone-capped spire on a cone of eroding Brule clay, the final stage of a butte’s life. Photo: Mike Tigas, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Astorians of Robert Stuart were probably the first non-Native people to see it, in 1813, and the fur trader Joshua Pilcher made the first recorded use of the name in 1827. It became a landmark on the Oregon, California and Mormon Trails, and nearby Scotts Bluff, a group of bluffs on the same river, was passed by more than 250,000 westward emigrants between 1843 and 1869. Sketches, journals and an 1897 photograph by Darton suggest Chimney Rock was taller when the emigrants first saw it; erosion and lightning have shortened it since. Watching it shrink over two centuries is the closest anyone gets to seeing the slow arithmetic of scarp retreat at work, and for the wider sandstone country where the Mittens stand, our guide to Monument Valley’s geography follows the same rocks across the whole valley.

Recently updated guides