Island vs Continent: Size, Crust and the Greenland–Australia Gap
Source: Wikimedia Commons
Geography Guides

Island vs Continent: Size, Crust and the Greenland–Australia Gap

Size is the everyday answer: Greenland is the largest island and Australia the smallest continent. Geology adds a firmer test of continental crust and shelves, with microcontinent Madagascar and sunken Zealandia blurring the line.

Geography Worlds
March 26, 2026
Updated October 10, 2026
7 min read

Greenland, at 2,166,086 km², is the largest island on Earth, and mainland Australia, at 7,617,930 km², is the smallest continent, so the practical difference between an island and a continent is size, with a gap of more than three and a half times between the two. Both are land surrounded by water, and no official size rule separates them; the line is a convention. Geology gives a firmer test: a continent is a large block of thick, silica-rich continental crust that includes its submerged continental shelf, while many islands are either small pieces broken off a continent, like Madagascar, or volcanic peaks built up from the ocean floor, like Iceland and Hawaiʻi.

Australia’s 7.6 Million km² Against Greenland’s 2.2 Million km²: Where Size Draws the Line

By convention, continents are large, continuous, separate masses of land, ideally divided by expanses of water. Taken literally, that makes every continent an island of a sort, so geographers fall back on size. Australia is the largest landmass that is not joined to another, and the smallest called a continent. Greenland is the largest landmass that is called an island, and the cut-off between the two is openly arbitrary. No landmass ringed by sea falls between 2.2 and 7.6 million km² to blur the gap, which is why the convention has held.

Mainland Australia7,617,930 km²
Greenland2,166,086 km²
New Guinea785,753 km²
Borneo748,168 km²
Madagascar592,800 km²
Baffin Island507,205 km²
The smallest continental landmass compared with the five largest islands. Madagascar’s figure is for the country. Source: Wikipedia articles on Continent, New Guinea, Borneo, Madagascar and Baffin Island

The other continents are far larger still. Asia covers more than 44 million km², about 30% of Earth’s land, and Antarctica 14.2 million km², almost double Australia. At the other end of the scale there is no agreed minimum size for an island. The word applies to land in lakes and rivers as well as seas, from Zeraf Island, a river island of about 8,000 km² between the White Nile and the Bahr el Zeraf in South Sudan, down to rocks a few metres across. The only common exclusion is land that is dry only at low tide.

Greenland itself shows how much of an island’s area can be something other than open land. Its 2,166,086 km² includes small offshore islands, and the Greenland ice sheet covers 1,755,637 km² of it, about 81%. Most of the island’s settlements cling to the ice-free coastal strip and its fjords. Next in line, Baffin Island in Canada’s Nunavut covers about 507,000 km² but had only 13,039 people at the 2021 census; its Inuktitut name, Qikiqtaaluk, simply means “very big island”.

The word continent itself began as a description of shape rather than size. It comes from the Latin terra continens, “continuous land”, and in the 17th century English writers spoke of the “continents”, meaning mainlands, of the Isle of Man, Ireland and Wales; one 1745 text applied it to Sumatra. Only gradually did it narrow to the handful of giant landmasses. The word island has its own odd history: it comes from Old English igland, and the silent s was added in the 15th century through a false link with the unrelated Old French isle. Even now the count is a matter of convention: most English-speaking countries teach seven continents, but other systems merge Europe and Asia into Eurasia, the Americas into one, or Africa, Europe and Asia into Afro-Eurasia, which together form a single continuous landmass.

Continental Crust and the Continental Shelf: The Geologist’s Test

Geologists define a continent by what it is made of rather than how big its coastline is. In geology a continent is one of Earth’s major landmasses, including both its dry land and its continental shelves. Four criteria are usually listed: it stands high relative to the ocean floor; it contains a wide range of igneous, metamorphic and sedimentary rocks rich in silica; its crust is thicker than the oceanic crust around it; and it covers a large, well-defined area. Continental crust of this kind is only known to exist on Earth.

Under this definition the true edge of a continent is the edge of its continental shelf, not the shoreline, because coastlines move as sea level rises and falls. That changes which islands count as part of a continent. Great Britain, at 209,331 km² the ninth-largest island in the world, sits on Europe’s shelf. Until about 9,000 years ago it was joined to what are now Denmark and the Netherlands by a low, marshy land bridge called Doggerland, which rising seas drowned at the end of the last ice age. Britain is therefore an island geographically but part of the European continent geologically.

The same logic explains why the Australian continent is bigger than the country’s mainland. The continent, sometimes called Sahul, includes mainland Australia, Tasmania and the island of New Guinea, linked by the shallow Arafura Sea, Torres Strait and Bass Strait. During the last glacial maximum, around 18,000 BC, they were one dry landmass. Counting all three, the continent covers about 8.56 million km² and is the smallest, lowest and flattest of the seven. New Guinea, the world’s second-largest island, is in this sense an island and a piece of a continent at once.

Madagascar and Zealandia: A Microcontinent and a Sunken Continent

Some land is made of continental crust but is too small, or too deeply submerged, to be ranked as a conventional continent. Geologists call these pieces microcontinents or continental fragments. Madagascar is the largest example above water. It is a fragment of the ancient supercontinent Gondwana that split from Africa around 180 million years ago, in the Early Jurassic, and from the Indian landmass about 90 million years ago. That long isolation produced a wildlife so distinct that biologists sometimes call it “the eighth continent”, even though geographers treat it as an island of Africa.

A rope suspension bridge crossing between jagged grey limestone pinnacles of the Tsingy de Bemaraha in western Madagascar
The limestone pinnacles of Tsingy de Bemaraha National Park in western Madagascar, the largest microcontinent above sea level. Photo: Cactus0625, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Zealandia shows how blurry the line can be. It is a mass of continental crust of about 4.9 million km², more than twice the size of Greenland and close to the size of Australia, that broke away from Gondwana between 83 and 79 million years ago and sank. About 94% of it is under the Pacific; New Zealand and New Caledonia are its highest parts. The geologist Bruce Luyendyk proposed the name in 1995, in 2017 a team of eleven geologists from New Zealand, New Caledonia and Australia concluded that it meets all the requirements of a submerged continent, and mapping of its full extent concluded in 2023. Some geologists still dispute its status because it seemed to lack very old Precambrian rocks, though a 2021 study found Precambrian crust in part of it. If it is counted, Earth has a continent that is almost entirely underwater. It is also larger than two landmasses often described as near-continents: the Arabian Peninsula, at 3,237,500 km² the world’s largest peninsula, and the Indian subcontinent, at about 4.3 million km². The Oxford English Dictionary defines a subcontinent as a large land mass somewhat smaller than a continent, yet both of those are attached to Asia, not surrounded by sea. Smaller pieces include the Kerguelen Plateau in the southern Indian Ocean and the northern Mascarene Plateau, which carries the Seychelles.

Iceland, Hawaiʻi and Great Britain: Oceanic Islands Versus Continental Islands

Islands themselves come in two broad families. Continental islands, like Great Britain, Newfoundland or Sri Lanka, sit on a continent’s shelf or broke away from one, and share much of their plant and animal life with the mainland. Oceanic islands were never part of a continent. They are built from the sea floor, mostly by volcanoes, and grow as coral atolls or sediment barrier islands. The difference shows in their wildlife: plants and animals reach oceanic islands only by crossing open water, so the species that arrive evolve in isolation. Islands of both kinds matter far beyond their size: up to 10% of the world’s population lives on islands, and low-lying island nations such as the Maldives, the Marshall Islands and Tuvalu are threatened with complete submergence by rising seas.

Iceland is the clearest example of an oceanic island, and it also shows why size alone cannot define a continent. Its main island covers 101,826 km², yet it is built of volcanic rock on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, the spreading boundary between the North American and Eurasian plates. At Silfra, in Þingvellir National Park, the plates pull apart by about 2 cm a year, and divers swim along the crack between them.

Snorkellers in clear blue water inside the narrow rocky Silfra fissure between moss-covered lava walls in Iceland
The Silfra fissure in Þingvellir National Park, Iceland, a rift between the North American and Eurasian plates. Photo: Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Hawaiʻi is the other textbook volcanic island, the south-eastern end of a chain of volcanoes in the North Pacific. The island of Hawaiʻi, the Big Island, covers 10,430 km², 63% of the land in the whole Hawaiian chain. Neither Iceland nor Hawaiʻi has the thick, old, silica-rich crust of a continent, and geologists do not count either as a microcontinent, unlike the largely volcanic Kerguelen Plateau, which is tied to the breakup of Gondwana.

Put together, the distinctions form a scale rather than a single line. At one end are oceanic islands made fresh from the sea floor; then continental islands sitting on a shelf; then microcontinents such as Madagascar and the largely sunken continental crust of Zealandia; and finally the continents themselves, where Australia is the smallest by convention. Greenland sits awkwardly in the middle of the list: geographers count it as part of North America, yet it is officially an island, a question we unpack in is Greenland an island or a continent. For the full ranking of what comes after it, see our list of the largest islands in the world, and for the many ways of counting the big landmasses, read how many continents there are.

Recently updated guides